But now, we embrace our spiritual differences. The first key question to as is: If the answer is yes then the relationship sounds like it's doomed.
Know that you are playing a game aka dating mormon girls that has low odds of success. As I grew and became confident, I learned how to deal with social awkwardness.
The divorce factor may allow some women to experience single-faith marriage at some point as some Mormon men marry multiple Mormon women over the course of their lifetimes, but the overall point stands: The only options for these women involve seeking a partner outside of the church, or a lifetime of celibacy.
They might be disappointed, or overjoyed, or judgmental, or supportive. Choose courses based on your needs.
When you make the best choice for you, blessings will follow. You need to do this ceremony first where you end up pledging all your money and property to the church: It's cruel to suggest it.